Masterson’s 10 yr. Straight Rye Review

Mastersons 10 yr Straight Rye Review
Masterson’s is definitely a nice rye. Though, like Whistle Pig, it suffers from a bit of an identity crises because it gets distilled up in Canada, but then gets brought down and bottled here in the states. Part of me wants to call it a Canadian whisky, because really that’s what it is, and the other part of me wants to throw a fit because, again, we have a company that’s doing their best to not say they distill it without saying they don’t distill it either.

The name Masterson’s comes from Bat Masterson who was a figure of some renown in the American old west and like this whiskey he was born in Canada, but came to America to find his fortune and fame. Early in life he left Canada to be a buffalo hunter and from there he became an Army Scout in the not-so-awesome Indian battles before becoming a well-known gambler, a lawman and finally the sports editor for the New York Telegraph. I wonder what he would think of this whiskey?

Masterson’s 10 yr. Straight Rye Review

Batch: 005
Bottle: 9450

ABV: 45%
Age: 10 years
Price: $70
Distiller: Alberta Distillers
Bottler: 35 Maple Street Spirits (CA)
Mashbill: 100% rye

EYE
Caramel

NOSE
RYE. Not kidding you, this 100% rye whiskey wondrously reeks of rye. Behind that are notes of caramel, pepper, leather, sweet tobacco and vanilla with a touch of wood, dill and baking spices. This is one hell of a nice smelling rye.

PALATE
Boom, that rye spice comes barreling out again bringing some great solid notes of caramel, cinnamon, pepper, nutmeg and leather. The tobacco notes have turned a bit bitter on the palate and the baking spices have taken on a bit more of a nutmeg and clove feel. The woody notes have firmed up and provide a great floor for some ambiguous sweet notes to flit about.

BALANCE, BODY & FEEL
This is a great balancing act with everything stacked and assembled in a tasty fashion. A warm full body fills out the whiskey and compliments it’s weighty feel.

FINISH
Can I just write “All Of The Above” and call it a day? No? Well ok then. It’s a nice long finish that is dominated by the rye, caramel and woody notes and punctuated with all the great pepper, leather, cinnamon, tobacco, vanilla and baking spice noted before. A very nice dram indeed.

OVERALL
This whiskey is good, but I feel that $70 is a bit too much for it. It feels like they are trying to take a page out of Masterson’s own book and capitalize on his name. Towards the end of his life Bat would supposedly buy six-shooters from pawn shops (buying the whiskey from Canada), put notches on it like he did after killing a man (bottling it and labeling it with his name) and then selling it as the original for an inflated price (selling it as “artisan crafted” without saying whose artisans crafted it… for an inflated price). Definitely worth a try… but I’d hold off on buying a whole bottle till you did.

SCORE: 86-90 /100*

 

*Range given because I was trying it at a friend’s house and not in a controlled environment at home. Also, the image shows a frosted bottle. I did warm mine in my hand until body temperature before taking notes.

Josh Peters
Connect

Josh Peters

I read about, think about, write about, and drink whisk(e)y. In short, it's my passion.
Josh Peters
Connect

Latest posts by Josh Peters (see all)

7 Responses to Masterson’s 10 yr. Straight Rye Review

  1. Hey Josh,

    You are closer with the 90 grade, fantastic rye, right there for me with E H Taylor Rye IMO.(Of course there is Lot 40 which nothing is better than)

    Cheers

  2. Hey Josh

    Have you purchased a bottle yet?

    You need to have this in your bar. This is on a par with Whistlepig and it ain’t cheap either.

    See if you can get yourself some Millstone 100 rye from Holland, pricey but ridiculously good.

    Your reviews are a must read for me.

    Cheers

  3. I’ve kept an eye on this one since Whistlepig is one of my favorite ryes (up there with jep 15, which has similar pretensions to Masterson’s but is still tremendous) and AD products aren’t easy to come by South of the border. I finally came across a bottle that was selling for less than I was used to seeing (normally in the low 60s) and snatched it.
    Honestly, it was pretty disappointing at first. I was expecting the bombastic character of WP but what i got was far closer to a Crown Royal product (say, Monarch, but spicier). Given a bit of time it has… EVOLVED. Perfume on the nose (light spice and a complete absence of wood character), subtly sweet but not drying in the way ryes can be (perhaps this is due to the relatively low proof?) and a pleasant, but not indulgent, finish with some nice generic “fruit”. Nothing at all astringent (quite unusual in my experience).
    Like another poster has said, I think 90 is closer to the mark, regardless of provenance.

  4. Would love to know the history of the Masterson’s etched and numbered bottle I have. Almost feels like crystal bottle, very heavy,very lovely glass lines and numbered batch 015 bottle 9576.

Leave a reply

Send this to a friend