Writer’s Tears Irish Whiskey Review

Writer's Tears Irish Whiskey Review

Writer’s Tears Irish Whiskey is a brilliant whiskey… I just wish that it was fuller and richer and they messed with it less. A combination of rich, buttery, fruity and copper Irish Single Malt and Single Pot Still whiskey it’s a thing of beauty. Truly, it is… or at least it could be.

In Walsh Whiskey Distillery’s Words: Writer’s Tears

“Writerṣ Tears” is a unique old Irish Pot still Whiskey. It is a vatting of Single Malt and Single Pot Still whiskeys. Distilled from 60% malt and 40% pot Still (No Grain). Writers Tears is triple distilled, non -peated and matured and aged in American Oak bourbon casks.

A gold Medal winner at the International Spirits Challenge in London and one of the highest rated Irish Whiskeys in Jim Murrays Iconic “Whiskey Bible” “Altogether a very unusual Irish Whiskey , a throwback to the last century where spiced Pure Pot Still whiskey was married with Floral Single Malt” –Jim Murray . It has also been added to Ian Buxton’s publication “101 Whiskeys to try before you die.”

Ok, maybe I was a little harsh with the “could be”. As you’ll see in the Writer’s Tears Irish Whiskey review below I think it’s a good whiskey. I just think it could be even better if it was treated properly and delivered in a closer-to-natural state. Keep all those lovely oils and I bet this whiskey would sky rocket into the A- and above range without even glancing behind it.

Writer’s Tears Irish Whiskey Info

Region: Ireland

Distiller: Midleton
Bottler: Walsh Whiskey Distillery
Mashbill: Irish Single Malt & Irish Single Pot Still (60% Malted & 40% un-Malted Barley)
Cask: ex-Bourbon
Age: NAS (3+ years)
ABV: 40%

Price: $40

Writer’s Tears Irish Whiskey Review

Apple juice

Malt, caramel, vanilla beans, toffee, fruit, oily spice and a bit of copper. It might be a bit limited in scope, but the richness of what’s there is quite nice.

Malt, caramel, toffee, orchard fruit, vanilla, dynamic dark sweets, creamy vanilla and some copper with a bit of lemon and hazelnuts. I’m a bit surprised by the richness.

Medium fade of malt, cinnamon oil, toffee, vanilla and fruit.

Good sense of balance, medium body and a feel that’s heavier and oilier than I’d expect for 40%.

Writer’s Tears Irish Whiskey is remarkable. I was not expecting to like a 40%, young, chill-filtered whiskey as much as I am. The blend of Irish Single Malt and Irish Single Pot Still creates a richness and depth that blows past my expectations and has me sitting here smiling like an idiot while typing this up and sipping on a glass.

Rich and heavy it has layers of sweeter fruity flavors and darker malty and candy flavors and aromas that balance each other out quite well. I can’t even imagine what the Writer’s Tears Irish Whiskey would be like at cask strength. I saw that they put one out so I guess I’m going to have to do some hunting.

SCORE: 87/100 (B+)

Writer's Tears Irish Whiskey Review - Score Breakdown
  • Nose - 87
  • Palate - 88
  • Finish - 87
  • Balance, Body & Feel - 88


Writer's Tears Irish Whiskey is great

Writer's Tears Irish Whiskey Label

Josh Peters

Josh Peters

I read about, think about, write about, and drink whisk(e)y. In short, it's my passion.
Josh Peters

Latest posts by Josh Peters (see all)

One Response to Writer’s Tears Irish Whiskey Review

  1. For what it’s worth, I’m a writer, and I love this stuff. Of course the name is fanciful, since real writer’s tears are far too bitter to drink. But if you can find this, i think you’ll agree it’s one of the best whiskies going. As Josh implies, it’s almost shockingly good.

Leave a reply

Send this to a friend