Forty Creek Confederation Oak Review

Forty Creek Confederation Oak Review

Forty Creek Confederation Oak gets it’s name from the barrels it was aged in. All components of this whiskey spent some time aged in barrels made from Canadian oak trees that were over 150 years old which means they started growing before the Canadian Confederation (1867). On their site Forty Creek talks about the actual harvesting of the trees and makes it clear that they harvested these trees from…

“…a sustainably managed forest employing the principle of “no tree before its time.” This forest has a mixture of young trees coming up in the understory, mature trees in full productive vigor, and old trees whose growth has slowed. These older trees block sunlight and rainfall from the younger trees and when over-matured, need to be removed.”

Like with the Forty Creek Barrel Select, Master Distiller John Hall distills the corn, rye and barley separately to be aged and blended together later in what he calls his “Meritage Process”. Once they’re ready the separate whiskeys get blended together and allowed to fully marry in the barrels they just came out of. However, with the Forty Creek Confederation Oak that marrying process happens in toasted barrels made from the Confederation-era Oak mentioned above and lasts for 3 years.

Forty Creek Confederation Oak Info

Region: Ontario, Canada

Distiller: Forty Creek
Mashbill: Rye Whisky + Barley Whisky + Corn Whisky
Cask: ex-Bourbon Barrels & Canadian Oak Barrels
Age: NAS
ABV: 40%

Lot: 1867-E
Bottle: 07579

Price: $70*

Forty Creek Confederation Oak Review

Deep amber

Butterscotch, milk duds, sweet grain and a light candied citrus paired with some fresh pastries. The grainy sweetness rides high throughout the aroma.

Butterscotch-toffee-caramel hybrid (dark sweets), toasted corn, candy corn and a light dilly spice that grows towards the end. The grainy sweetness is a bit more oily here and gets a touch more balanced out by the slightly heavier spice when compared to the nose.

Medium and darkly sweet with some grain, vanilla and nutty notes.

Balance is off due to the sweetness, a medium body and a light syrupy feel.

Forty Creek Confederation Oak isn’t fully my style of whisky. It’s a bit too sweet and runs across the senses in a way that builds to become a cloying butterscotch bomb and the only saving grace is the bit of spice that keeps it from tumbling into overly sweet one notedness. It’s becoming rather clear to me that Canadian Whisky just isn’t my thing.

There are some Canadian whiskies out there I love like Stalk & Barrel and Lot 40, but this blended style of Canadian whisky doesn’t seem to resonate with me. The Forty Creek Confederation Oak is definitely one of the better ones I’ve had in this style, but for my money their Copper Pot Reserve is where it’s at if you’re looking to pick up one of their releases.

SCORE: 82/100 B-

*Disclosure: This sample of Forty Creek Confederation Oak was graciously sent to me by the company for the purposes of this review. The views, opinions, and tasting notes are 100% my own.
Forty Creek Confederation Oak Review - Score Breakdown
  • Nose - 82
  • Palate - 84
  • Finish - 83
  • Balance, Body & Feel - 79


Forty Creek Confederation Oak is not my style, but if you like Canadian Whisky then chances are you'd love this.

Forty Creek Confederation Oak Label

Josh Peters

Josh Peters

I read about, think about, write about, and drink whisk(e)y. In short, it's my passion.
Josh Peters

Latest posts by Josh Peters (see all)

2 Responses to Forty Creek Confederation Oak Review

  1. Josh,

    You have to get a better pipeline for Canadian Whisky, Wiser’s Legacy or Red Letter are the one’s you want to try.

    Stalk & Barrel cask strength is a Single malt, not really a Canadian Whisky profile.


    • I’ve seen a Wiser’s here in LA, not sure if it’s Legacy, but never seen the Red Letter. Los Angels isn’t a big town for Canadian whisky, it’s mostly the stuff I’ve been reviewing unfortunately. Totally understand S&B is a single malt, but it’s a darn good one!

Leave a reply

Send this to a friend